Why do we allow grades to determine our self worth?
February 22, 2022
We’ve all been there: you open your Chromebook and log into Q. You check your grade in an important class only to find that it has substantially dropped all due to one quiz, and can’t help but feel downtrodden.
This scenario is all too common in high school these days. The pressure to succeed in school can be extremely intense, to the point where students will sacrifice both their mental and physical health just to get a good grade. Worse, when they don’t achieve their desired grade, they allow it to have a huge impact on their self-esteem.
The desire to get a good grade can become mentally consuming. It’s easy to lose sleep over that one question you missed, or that historical event you should have brought up in your essay. Pressure to get a good grade is overbearing due to the looming presence of academic stress, especially in the first couple of years in high school. Ashley Newman ‘22 claims “I think when I was younger, I was really, really stressed about grades, and I really wanted that academic validation and that feeling that you get when you get a good grade and are really proud of yourself.” Pressure to do well in school stems from the academic validation that Newman describes.
The desire for academic validation from parents, peers, teachers and even from oneself oftentimes contributes to why we allow grades to determine our own self-worth. When asked about why she stresses about grades, Sienna Darlicuio ‘23 claims “I have a lot of pressure from other students, my teachers and my parents… I feel like there’s always this standard to get good grades all the time.” There is an undeniable pressure to get good grades, as it is a measure of success in our society. However, it is not the only measure of success; a grade represents one small part of who we are at a single moment in time.
Academics should (rightfully) be one of a student’s top priorities. However, to become consumed with the pressure of achieving perfect grades is unhealthy for both the student and those surrounding them. Rather, a pleasant high school experience outside the classroom is just as important as academic commitment. Balance is crucial for a high school student; maintaining relationships between peers and family should be as equally important as an upcoming math benchmark. Surely, academics are important, but grades only reflect one aspect of a person, such as the ability to memorize. In other words, grades fail to show other, just as important aspects of an individual, especially the soul behind the score.
The academic grading system, though designed to gain insight into a student’s understanding, has become a large determinant of a student’s self-worth. The pressure placed through external (as well as internal) sources has left students with not only a desire but a need for a perfect grade. Achieving perfection is impossible, and unfulfilling. The exhausting chase for perfect grades will leave students burned out as the school year progresses, as well as a negative connotation with academics and self-worth. Rather than perfection, effort and progress are equally important accomplishments to be proud of. As I have been reminded by the supportive Foothill Technology High School (Foothill Tech) staff, progress is to be prioritized over perfection.
Eliza • Jun 23, 2024 at 2:08 pm
After successfully changing my poor grades by maverick and i was able to graduate as one of the best students and finally working in well paid organization, you’re only hurting yourself if you pretend your grades don’t matter.. visit Maverick Angelos today for grades change at bluehackangels407 Gmail com . Colleges look at grades, scholarship organizations look at grades, and employers look at grades too. However, you don’t need to have a 4.0 to be successful. But Good Grades can show every amazing quality you have, and colleges, scholarship organizations, and employers understand that too. Your school degree does not determine your life. However, good performance can earn you a good reputation and success.
John Doe • Dec 13, 2022 at 11:58 pm
There is a quote that I think exemplifies what one should strive for in academia.
“Perfection is unachievable. But if we strive for perfection, we can achieve excellence.” -Vince Lombardi (American football coach and executive in the National Football League)
Weirdly, the quote comes from a football coach. But, this coach knows what he’s saying.
Cherie Eulau • Feb 23, 2022 at 1:43 pm
I agree that the entire grading system needs to be changed. I highly recommend the book The End of Average and Upgrading or anything by Alfie Kohn. We just talked about this issue in Ethnic Studies!
Chris • Feb 23, 2022 at 10:16 am
Thank you for bringing light to this topic. I feel like everything comes down to this competitive and broken system. In reality, good grades only come down to if you complete your school work or not. It has nothing to do on how smart you actually are. You can be the smartest on earth, but if you don’t do your work, you have an F. Grades are the only thing that matters to the school system. The grade system makes the smartest feel stupid, and the stupid feel like the smartest.